8 Best Sweeteners for Keto Diets – Reviews & Buyer’s Guide 2019

(Last Updated On: November 14, 2019)

–Sugar, we all pretty much love it but only if it were a lot more healthier instead of just being sweet.

We have tried quite a lot of the healthier natural sugar alternatives, basically, the best keto-friendly sweeteners listed below are suitable for people with diabetes and they can at the same time prevent the onset of diabetes for those who are at risk.

Sure they can be more pricey than regular sugar, but when it comes to health, you can end up saving in the long run, especially when it comes to medical bills.

medical bills
Sugar has been said to be a contributing factor to most lifestyle diseases such as diabetes, high blood pressure, cancer, etc.

Many people find it hard to remove sugar from their diets altogether, especially when it comes to snacks and drinks.

As you know, it is not that easy finding the right sweeteners, but the good news is, we’ve done our best in taking the time to find out what’s out there and making sure that they’re good!

There are many opinions and views on the internet, but it all comes down to a matter of taste (personal preference), and of course, there’s always something for everyone.

Below you will find the best sugar substitutes for 2019, which have high ratings from many satisfying customers.

 


best sugar sweeteners

1. Lakanto – Monkfruit Sweetener

lakanto monkfruit sweetener
NET WT. 48 OZ (3LB) 1361 g

The fruits of Luo Han Guo which is Monk fruit has been used in China as a traditional medicine for the treatment of lung congestion, colds, sore throats and is also used as a sweetener for hundreds of years.

The steep forested area where monk fruit grows, known to a large number of Buddhist temples.

Monks used the fruit as the main ingredient in cooling drinks to neutralize the hot weather, and for fevers, chronic cough and throat inflammation, constipation, and diabetes.

It has, however, proved to be a keto-friendly sweetener, and the pure monk fruit is 100 to 300 times sweeter than regular sugar.

It is suitable for people with diabetes as it has zero calories, zero glycemic index, zero carbohydrates, and sugars in addition to improving blood sugar regulation.

Also, due to it being over 100 times sweeter than other sweeteners, you only have to use a little, and another good thing about it is, it doesn’t raise your blood sugar, and it doesn’t increase your insulin levels.

This “Lakanto Monkfruit Sweetener” is the right product for diabetics, keto, candida, paleo, vegan, and low-carb diets, and excellent in creating desserts, to bake or to cook with it.

lakanto monkfruit sweetener nutrition facts
INGREDIENTS: Erythritol, Monk Fruit Extract

You can measure it 1:1 just like sugar because it’s mixed with Non-GMO Erythritol along with Monk fruit extract, that’s why it’s not 300 times sweeter than sugar in its natural state.

Why is the monk fruit sweetener so expensive?
It’s not a natural plant to cultivate; this wild plant species are rare. It grows on shady slopes, which are often covered in fog and thus provide further protection from intense sunlight.

The manufacturer recommends trying in small doses at first to screen out the potential of any adverse reactions.

Pros

• Zero net carbs,zero calories and zero glycemic sweetener
• Does not impact blood sugar levels
• All natural
• Contains anti-inflammatory properties
• It won’t increase your insulin
• It’s Non-GMO
• No bitter aftertaste
• It tastes like sugar
• 1:1 sugar replacement

Cons

• It can cause diarrhea, stomach cramps/discomfort, headache and bloating
• You might get a cooling effect in your mouth

current price

 

2. Pyure – Organic Stevia

pyure organic stevia blend
NET WT. 16 OZ (1 LB) 454 g

Also known as sugar leaf, stevia is an extract that is nutrient-free with zero calories and is used as a food supplement.

Stevia is 200-300 times sweeter than table sugar, and it cannot metabolize as it maintains stability under all temperatures.

Stevia is a diabetic- and keto-friendly sweetener as it helps reduce blood pressure, lowers insulin and glucose in the blood, and also fights inflammation.

It is also recommended for people who are obese, have heart disease, and metabolic syndrome.

For the right balance, you can combine Stevia with Erythritol together, to avoid the bitter aftertaste.

The “Pyure” brand is one of the leading stevia suppliers. They use the best erythritol and the best stevia, which are all organic.

pyure organic stevia nutrition facts
INGREDIENTS: Organic Erythritol, Organic Stevia Leaf Extract (REB A), Natural Flavor

Stevia is an excellent natural and organic solution to many chemicals such as artificial sweeteners, which can reduce the two major epidemics in the United States, and that is diabetes and obesity; it’s a big problem right now.

The Pyure brand discovered how to isolate the sweetest parts of the plant, eliminating bitter elements and extracting fresh pieces.

This Pyure Organic Stevia is granulated, its a blend of organic Stevia and organic erythritol, so it’s already combined, you won’t taste the bitterness.

You can use it for cooking, baking, coffee, tea, actually you can sweeten everything with it, but the measuring is not 1:1 like sugar, it’s 1 tsp of Pyure Stevia = 2 tsp of sugar.

The Pyure ORGANIC Stevia has a taste and texture that closely mimics natural sugar if you don’t like a bitter taste, this is the right product, it tastes good, and it’s cheaper than the other products.

Pros

• It has zero calories, zero net carbs, zero GI, gluten-free, is sugar-free
• One only uses a little of it since its 300 sweeter than table sugar
• It’s perfect for diabetic, keto, paleo candida lifestyle
• Available in powder and liquid form
• No bitter aftertaste
• No effects on blood sugar levels
• Non-GMO
• Competitive price

Cons

• Has a cooling aftertaste
• Causes digestive problems in some people
• Doesn’t taste 100% like sugar
• Causes gas and bloating in some people

current price

 

3. Anthony’s Erythritol

anthony's erythritol
NET WT. 2.5 LB (1.13 kg)

Erythritol is a sugar alcohol sweetener extracted from corn but found in its natural form in some vegetables and fruits.

Recent studies show that Erythritol does not interfere with insulin or blood sugar in healthy persons. It is also not metabolized in the mouth, which means that it doesn’t cause cavities.

Erythritol is always one of the best choices because the GI (Glycemic index ) of it is zero; it has low calorie, low net carbs, always make sure that it’s Non-GMO.

People with diabetes can use it as it improves the function of blood vessels, thus reducing risks of heart disease.

Considered the safest sugar alcohol Erythritol is the most well-tolerated in terms of digestive discomfort.

For the right balance, you can combine Erythritol with Stevia or Erythritol with Xylitol together, to avoid the bitterness or cooling aftertaste.

The benefits of “The Anthony’s Erythritol Sweetener” is, it’s premium Non-GMO, 70% as sweet as table sugar, is gluten-free, has zero calories, has a low glycemic impact, it’s pure, and it’s Non-Blended.

anthonys erythritol nutrition facts nutrition facts
INGREDIENT: Erythritol

The best thing about this product is the fact that it has no aftertaste, unlike some other sugar substitutes like stevia.

It’s delicious, very clean, and it’s easy to use, but it’s not a 1:1 ratio compared to the sweetness of real sugar.

A good tip is, you can use the same amount of regular sugar as erythritol, it will come out less sweet, and you will start to reduce the amounts of sweets in your diet.

The price is not bad for 2.5 lb (1.13kg), and one more thing, if you use too much, it can give you a cooling effect in taste, but it’s much better than many other options available on the market.

Pros

• It has zero calories
• Does not interfere with insulin or blood sugar
• Does not cause dental cavities
• It’s Non-GMO
• It has a low glycemic impact
• Useful in many recipes
• Does not have the aftertaste
• It’s suitable for diabetics and low-carb diet

Cons

• Causes gas and bloating in some people
• Can cause digestive problem
• It is not as sweet as other sweeteners

current price

 

4. Swerve Sweetener

swerve sweetener double pack
NET WT. 12 OZ (340 g), PACK OF 2
swerve sweetener granular
NET WT. 12 OZ (340 g), PACK OF 1 GRANULAR
swerve sweetener granular nutrition facts
INGREDIENTS: Erythritol, Oligosaccharides, Natural Flavors

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

swerve sweetener confectioners
NET WT. 12 OZ (340 g), PACK OF 1 CONFECTIONERS
swerve sweetener confectioners nutrition facts
INGREDIENTS: Erythritol, Oligosaccharides, Natural Flavors

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

“Swerve Sweetener” company helps educate consumers on the danger of excessive sugar consumption.

They committed to sourcing only the highest quality raw materials available. All ingredients are sourced from the United States and Europe.

Swerve sweetener is made from naturally occurring ingredients such as erythritol, oligosaccharides, and natural flavors.

It contains no calories or carbs in addition to being non-glycemic, making it suitable for diabetics and keto people, as it does not elevate blood sugar.

Oligosaccharides sourced from select fruits and starchy root vegetables (that have been given enzymes to break it down), you will get this nondigestible fiber, that can help stimulate beneficial bacteria in your gut.

The company doesn’t tell you what kind of root vegetables they use to make the oligosaccharides.

They don’t tell you if these natural flavors are healthy or not, but it’s safe to consume it since we always check our blood sugar levels, which didn’t raise at all.

Swerve is the one we use a lot, the good thing is, it has a granulated version and a powdered version.

As it is a 1:1 replacement, which is fantastic to measure it just like sugar, it’s easy to cook, to bake, or even to make cold desserts with, Anh-Tu’s favorites.

It tastes identical to regular to white granulated sugar; the only downside is, it becomes a solid hard mass even when placed it into a sealed container.

Swerve sweetener has also proven to its users that it’s an excellent sugar replacement, delicious, along with a competitive price in comparison to other keto sweetener alternatives, we highly recommend it.

Pros

• zero net carbs
• Tastes like table sugar
• It’s safe for pets
• 1:1 sugar replacement
• No bitter aftertaste
• It doesn’t impact your blood sugar or insulin levels
• Non-GMO
• Competitive price
• It’s diabetic- and keto-friendly

Cons

• As it is a sugar alcohol, it can cause digestive problems in some people
• Can cause a slightly cooling aftertaste for some people
• Can cause intense bloating and constipation

current price

 

5. Just Like Sugar – From Chicory Root

just like sugar baking
NET WT. 16 OZ (453.59 g)

Chicory root is a crop processed from the root of a plant, which is a perennial plant of the dandelion family with blue flowers.

You can use the leaves and the roots of this plant, it has medicinal purposes and can also be a coffee alternative.

It’s a wild plant and its native in Europe, but now it has become widely naturalized in North America, China, and Australia.

Chicory root contains large amounts of soluble fiber and vital minerals.

It also helps in the prevention of constipation, maintains bacteria balance in the colon, lowers cholesterol in the blood; it supports the liver, the heart, it’s anti-inflammatory and anti-cancer.

Also suitable for people with diabetes, helping with the reduction of cholesterol, which is excellent for blood pressure.

The ingredients for the product “Just Like Sugar” are a source of natural dietary fiber obtained from Chicory Root, Calcium, and Vitamin C.

just like sugar baking nutrition facts
Chicory Root Dietary Fiber, Calcium, Vitamin C, Natural Flavors from the Peel of the Orange

We like this product because it doesn’t contain soy, yeast, animal derivatives, or preservatives, keep in mind that the measuring won’t be the same as sugar.

Just Like Sugar does have a little bit of an aftertaste, which some people find not to their liking, but we don’t mind it ourselves since it’s diabetic- and keto-friendly.

As with any natural sweetener out there, you have to learn how to use it so that you get the taste desired.

Pros

• zero carbs and zero calories
• Diabetic- and keto-friendly
• Reduces inflammation
• It won’t promote tooth decay
• It’s all natural, gluten free and dairy free
• It has natural flavors from the peel of an orange
• Very good for baking
• It does not have the cooling effect

Cons

• Causes bloating and gas if used in excess hence should be used in moderation
• It might have a slightly bitter taste that may be unpleasant to some people
• It might cause allergic reaction

current price

 

6. Sukrin Gold – Brown Sugar Alternative

sukrin gold brown sugar
NET WT. 1.1 LB (500 g)

“Sukrin Gold Brown Sugar Alternative” has natural ingredients made of stevia, malt extract, tagatose and erythritol extracted from corn starch that is Non-GMO through natural fermentation.
It has no additives, artificial colors, or preservatives.
It has a GI of 1, making it ideal for individuals with diabetes as it does not affect insulin levels or blood sugar. It also has a rich taste aroma that makes it suitable for any food that uses sugar.
It looks like brown sugar, it has the same consistency, it smells like it, and the taste is also very close, in all of the recipes.
The texture is that of brown sugar, slightly moist, and sticks together, and you even can caramelize it, which is very important in some Asian dishes.

sukrin gold brown sugar nutrition facts
INGREDIENTS: Erythritol, Steviol, Glycosides (Stevia), Malt Extract, Tagatose

It is only eight calories per 3.5 oz (100g) that makes 372 fewer calories than brown sugar.

It’s also perfect for cakes, cookies, yogurt, coffee/tee, sauces, etc. which is excellent for a brown sugar alternative; you can even measure it just like sugar.

Sukrin is suitable for people who follow a low-carb diet, gluten-free, high in fiber, have diabetes, or for anyone cutting back on sugar.

It might be expensive for you, but when you need something as close to real brown sugar as possible, this product would be a great replacement.

Pros

• Has few calories (98% less than table sugar)
• Non-GMO
• Diabetic- and keto-friendly
• Does not interfered with blood sugar levels
• Gluten free with zero fats and zero proteins
• Can be used in recipes to replace other sugars
• Does not contain additives, all natural
• Aspartame free
• 97% less carbs than table sugar
• No hidden carbs
• No contaminated ingredients
• 1:1 sugar replacement

Cons

• It might have a slight cooling aftertaste for some people
• Can cause bloating and gas
• Difficult to dissolve

current price

 

7. Lakanto – Maple Flavored Syrup

lakanto maple syrup
NET WT. 13 FL OZ (384 ml)

The “Lakanto Maple Flavored Syrup” contains numerous benefits such as low Glycemic, lower calories, gluten-free, and has all-natural ingredients in it like non-GMO monk fruit sweetener (erythritol and monk fruit extract).

The producer combined erythritol with monk fruit to make it a 1:1 sugar replacement, comparable to other syrups; the texture cannot easily be replicated with monk fruit only.

This maple syrup is suitable for the keto-diet, diabetics, candida, paleo, and vegan, actually for everyone who wants to cut down on sugary Syrup for a healthier lifestyle.

When you pour the Syrup out on a plate, you will notice that it will spread out a little bit, it’s not as thick as regular syrups.

Lakanto Maple Flavored Syrup is easy to use in crepes, cakes, waffles, pancakes, coffee, tea, yogurt, etc. so it shouldn’t be a big deal about its thickness.

It doesn’t taste exactly like maple syrup, so don’t expect it to, because it’s a replacement that is healthier.

We know it’s confusing because the title says “Maple,” but it’s “Maple Flavoured Syrup,” and the flavor will have a slight difference in taste.

After opening, it has to be refrigerated, should be consumed within 90 days. Ninety days are quite short for us since we are only two and don’t use it every day.

If you’re a waffle, pancakes, coffee, or a tea lover who enjoys maple-flavored Syrup, this is the product for you without feeling guilty.

It’s a little bit pricey, but you pay for what you get since there are healthy ingredients and no chemicals inside, Lakanto Maple Flavored Syrup is of excellent quality and is worth trying!

Pros

• No artificial impurities – all natural
• Good for keto-diet, diabetics, candida, paleo and vegan
• Lower Calories and it’s Gluten Free
• Low Glycemic
• Only 1 net carb
• It’s sugar-free
• It doesn’t affect your blood sugar
• Sweet to the taste
• No bitter aftertaste

Cons

• Not as thick
• Might have an aftertaste
• Consume within 90 days after opening
• It doesn’t taste like maple syrup
• Pricey for a syrup

current price

 

8. Morning Pep – Xylitol

morning pep xylitol
NET WT. 5 LB (2267 g)

Xylitol is another sugar alcohol that is available in vegetables and fruits that tastes just like sugar though it is 40% less caloric.

Xylitol inhibits the growth of oral harmful bacteria and maximizes the absorption of calcium by teeth, which is essential for the prevention of cavities. Due to these health benefits, xylitol is in chewing gums.

It can cause gastrointestinal discomfort, so be careful when consuming it. Otherwise, you may experience bloating, along with gas and intestinal disturbances and diarrhea. However, it’s still a better alternative substitute.

The “Morning Pep” it’s ideal for coffee, tea cereal, baking, or any other use, made in the USA, xylitol is extracted from 100% birch (not from corn) are of the highest quality and benefit.

It looks and tastes like sugar with no aftertaste; it’s safe for diabetics; it has fewer calories, low carb, and a low glycemic index.

morning pep xylitol nutrition facts
100% Pure Birch Xylitol

The benefits, it’s kosher and free of GMO, corn, wheat, gluten, soy, and dairy.

It’s rich in minerals such as potassium, calcium, magnesium, manganese, zinc, phosphorus, iron, sodium, amino acids, and it is also rich in vitamin C.

The taste is pretty sweet, very pure, very natural, it doesn’t taste like it’s a chemical in your mouth, and surprisingly it tastes like real table sugar.

Dentists recommend it, as it helps in preventing tooth decay. Be aware that it can be extremely toxic to dogs and other pets.

If you want good Xylitol at a reasonable price, made from 100 % birch trees, not corn, we recommend this brand and seller.

Pros

• Tastes like table sugar but with 40% fewer calories
• Improves dental health
• 100% pure natural sweetener
• Low glycemic
• Low carbohydrates
• Diabetic- and keto-friendly
• Reduces tooth decay
• Is allergen free

Cons

• Causes bloating, gassiness or diarrhea in some people
• Can cause digestive problems
• Can be toxic to dogs and other pets

current price

 

Eat Sugar-Free – Start Cleaning Your Body

Eating sugar-free doesn’t mean you can consume artificial sweeteners.

Sure it won’t affect your blood sugar levels, but it can create problems such as heart disease, irritable bowel syndrome, and promotes liver inflammation, etc.

Artificial sweeteners are synthetically produced products that are much sweeter than sugar, which means 30 to 3000 times sweeter than sugar.

It can be found mainly in sweet drinks, they have almost no calories and the disadvantage is, they do not saturate, studies have proven that we consume artificial sweeteners even more than regular sugar.

That’s why we don’t use it at all.

 

A Healthy Life Which Will Payoff

The healthier lifestyle is growing, and more consumers are searching for non-chemical products, organic or natural sugar sweeteners, that won’t affect their health later.

You have to make some effort; it’s worth trying, you may be spending a little bit more money for healthier alternative substitutes.

But in the long run, your body will thank you, and you will feel much better, far less inflammation, along with lots of savings on health bills!

It‘s never too late to start!

 

How to Choose The Right Sugar Substitutes

You might have the urge for something sweet.

Still, there are many ways to satisfy yourself with different kinds of sweeteners, which are categorized in natural sweeteners often produced from plants, sugar alcohols, synthetic, or artificial sweeteners.

You have to pay close attention; not every product is natural as claimed.

Not knowing what to look for can be overwhelming, see what works best for you. Go through the product description and use the following factors.

Side-Effects

For some people, sweeteners with sugar alcohol can cause gas, bloating, diarrhea, or digestive problems, but it doesn’t mean that you’ll experience these issues too; there are more preferable options available.

Good Benefits

Some keto sweeteners have significant benefits, such as a reduction in blood pressure, lower blood glucose and insulin levels, anti-inflammatory, contain fewer calories, and help with dental health.

Keto Sweeteners are a healthier alternative, but as with sugar do not exaggerate with consuming, too much is also not suitable, you may crave for sweets even more.

What to Look for

When buying sweeteners, you should also look out for levels of carbohydrates in the sweetener; you don’t want to overeat and affect your blood sugar levels.

Some substitutes are more for cooking, and others are for baking, but most sweeteners are for both.
Don’t forget always to check if it’s diabetic-friendly if you don’t want to raise your blood, glucose, or insulin levels.

Check Its GI

GI that is the Glycemic Index. The GI measures the level of food or drinks increase your blood sugar, which means, it indicates how high and how fast the blood sugar level rises after the consumption of a particular food.

The best sweetener should have the lowest GI, and better is 0.

Check Ingredients on The packaging

Make sure that it’s Non-GMO, organic, healthy, natural, from clean sources, and that it’s a natural sugar.

As you know, artificial sweeteners like aspartame (Equal or NutraSweet), saccharin (Sweet’N Low), sucralose (Splenda), or Truvia are not good at all.

Look for clean sweeteners, avoid products that contain sweeteners such as maltodextrin, dextrose, or polydextrose.

Don’t be tricked with sugar-free products that have an ingredient such as maltitol; it still has a high GI (Glycemic index).

Last Check

Don’t be shocked if you see high total carbs, always subtract fiber and sugar alcohols when calculating, resulting in net carbs.

Net carbs are the real numbers, especially when it comes to keeping track of your macros (macronutrients).

A lot of these sweeteners have fiber that goes into the digestive system, and your microbes interact with it, if you don’t have the enzymes to break it down or if it’s not going through, it can create a lot of issues.

However, before deciding on the type of sweetener you want to use, you should consider your state of health as some sweeteners are not fit for some health conditions.

The keto-friendly sweeteners listed above are suitable for people with diabetes, and they can, at the same time, prevent the onset of diabetes for those who are at risk.

 

Conclusion

getting fit
Get Healthy Now – It’s Time to Change

So it is best to forget the sugar!

These alternative sweeteners are all plant-based and all-natural… and last but not least, a thousand times healthier than the typical unhealthy sugar that we have all come to know.

We all know sugar affects your teeth, makes you fat, and is super unhealthy, but you face it every day, whether at home, at your job, in your food/drinks, your surroundings, etc.

Also, only a few people know about the hidden sugars in many of the products that we consume. Our advice is that you pay attention to the ingredients before buying anything.

Remember that no sugar substitute is perfect. We have tried many different keto-friendly sweeteners at the start of our healthy living journey.

It has been an enormous task in finding the right product for each of us, as our tastes are different.

We hope that we’ve made your decision easier even if it was… bitter…sweet (hashtag) HA!

Sharing is Caring!

  1. Dovey

    I am glad that I landed on your page. I have just recently been told by my doctor that I am prediabetic. I have been looking for a sugar substitute, but I do not like most of them. The after taste always gets to me.

    After reading your review, I am excited to try the couple that you mention have no aftertaste. Although I will be honest, I do not know what a “cooling in the mouth effect” is.

    Thank you for doing such a thorough review. I will be sure to read some of your other articles as I have to embrace a whole new lifestyle that I know nothing about.

  2. Lynn

    I know what someone with diabetes has to go through as my father is a diabetic. I have to control his diet strictly as he was hospitalized quite often when his diet was out of control. Sometimes, I feel rather guilty stopping him to eat cakes and snacks. I am really inspired by this post to bake cakes for my father using one of the mentioned substitutes! I am mentally prepared for some trial and error!

    I am also surprised that Luo Han Guo can be used to make into a sweetener! I know that this fruit tastes rather sweet as my mom always boil the fruit with some water whenever I catch a cold. However, I have never thought that it can be used as a sweetener! I have learnt something new!

  3. lena

    Very informative post. I am from china and did know the Luo Han Guo is very good for chronic cough and throat inflammation, but never know it can make it into sweetener. Too much sugar is bad for health, and I like the sweet thing, you post give me the new insight for the sugar substitute.

  4. Kelyee

    My husband is diabetic and he is a sugar fiend! We have been looking for a sugar substitute. I am so glad I found your website. It’s so thorough with all sorts of good information about a healthy alternative to table sugar.

    My doctor told me I also prediabetic too so I better be careful.

    Somehow the monk fruit sounds interesting. I’ll have to check that one out. But I’ll head out to get some stevia in the meantime because that’s everywhere.

    It’s funny how something good for you can also be bad for you.

  5. Janet

    Im glad I bumped into your site, that’s alot of good information for me since I have been trying to eat healthy and reduce my sugar intake.

    Although most of them tend to have these not so pleasant side effects lol! I’m gonna try some of those and hope to get one that fits me.

    Thanks for sharing.

  6. Kenny Lee

    Thanks for the list. Been looking to cut off some sugar and yet, without missing too much of the sweetened taste. I’ve been trying out stevia for a while, especially with coffee. Been loving it but I like having options.

  7. suzanne

    Hi and thanks for the awesome review.

    I’m diabetic and didn’t realize there were so many sugar alternatives. I’ve tried a few in the past, but never enjoyed the after taste.

    But some of these seem much newer with great possibilities. I especially like the brown sugar substitute. I really miss adding brown sugar to my oatmeal. I grew up doing that and it’s such a comfort food to me.

    The Just Like Sugar product looks great too. It’s so hard to bake with these substitutes, so maybe this one will be much easier to use. Plus the added bonus of fibre. 🙂

    Thanks again,
    Suzanne

Write a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *